How to Redesign a Website Without Losing SEO Ranking
Considering a redesign to your site and don’t want to lose the SEO visibility you’ve worked so hard to build? Then, this article is here to guide you with care, showing you how to refresh your website’s design while protecting the rankings, traffic, and trust you’ve already earned.
With clear and mindful steps, you’ll learn how to make design and SEO work hand in hand for long-term growth. And as you redesign your digital home, you’ll be creating a space that not only attracts visitors but also reflects the heart and purpose behind your business.
Why SEO Drops Happen During Redesign
There is a lot of speculation regarding whether a redesign should even be considered if your site is already performing well. As Foulkes reminds us, when done thoughtfully, a redesign can be an opportunity to strengthen your site’s SEO foundation and even improve your visibility in search results (Foulkes, 2014).
A redesign, however, is not without its ripple effects. Any changes to your site’s structure, design, or content can temporarily disrupt the way search engines understand and rank your pages.
This doesn’t mean a redesign is harmful. Quite the opposite; it simply means that extra care and planning are needed to protect the trust you’ve built with both search engines and your audience.
In many real-world scenarios, SEO often dips during redesigns because key elements are altered or overlooked, such as:
Shifting URLs without setting up proper redirects.
Removing or rewriting high-performing content.
Slowing down page speed with heavy visuals or code.
Forgetting mobile optimization or overlooking technical details like sitemaps and meta tags.
The good news is that with mindful attention to these details, you can preserve your hard-earned visibility while giving your site the fresh new look it deserves.
Pre-Redesign SEO Checklist: What You Should Be Aware Of
Before you begin reshaping your website’s look and feel, it’s essential to lay a foundation that will protect the visibility you’ve already worked so hard to build. Think of this checklist as a gentle safeguard; a way of making sure your redesign nurtures your business’s growth instead of unintentionally stalling it.
SEO Audit & Site Architecture Check
The very first step is a thorough SEO audit and a check of your site’s architecture. Imagine it as a way of understanding what’s working, what’s not, and where your site holds the most SEO strength.
Tools like Google Search Console or Screaming Frog can help you uncover indexing issues, broken links, or weak spots in your structure, but even a careful manual review can highlight valuable insights.
At our agency, we like to keep things simple and approachable for our clients, which is why we often use the SEOSpace plugin made specifically for Squarespace.
Once installed, it scans your entire site and provides a clear report highlighting where improvements may be needed in the form of a checklist, such as:
Missing or duplicate meta descriptions
Duplicate or poorly structured page titles
Slow-loading pages
Pages that aren’t properly linked within your site architecture
You don’t need to be a technical expert to understand the results, because the tool breaks them down into actionable insights you can work on step by step. With this snapshot in hand, you’ll know exactly which elements are strong and should be preserved, and which areas can be gently refined during your redesign.
Keywords & Rankings
Your current keyword rankings are like markers of trust that search engines already have in your site. By documenting these rankings before you make changes, you’ll have a clear way to measure whether the redesign supports or harms your visibility.
This process also helps you identify the ones that bring in the most traffic, so you can ensure their value is carried into the new design.
In Google Search Console, you can check the “Performance” tab to see which search queries your site is ranking for, along with impressions and clicks. To make the most of this data, focus on:
Identifying the keywords that already bring steady traffic.
Noting which pages rank best and contribute most to your visibility.
Preserving those pages and keywords during your redesign, since they act as the anchors of your SEO trust.
301 Redirect List
If your redesign involves changing page URLs, which often happens in larger sites, it’s vital to create a 301 redirect list.
Redirects act like forwarding addresses, telling search engines and visitors where to find your updated content, while preserving valuable link equity built over years.
In our experience, failing to plan redirects can result in painful drops in traffic. For small businesses, you may only need a handful of redirects, but the principle is the same: don’t leave your visitors or Google guessing.
In Squarespace, once you’ve created your list of old URLs and their new destinations, you can upload the following path, which ensures your link equity is preserved and your audience never lands on a dead end: Settings → Advanced → URL Mappings
The format is simple: you write your old page slug, then an arrow, then the new page slug, followed by the type of redirect. For example:
/old-services → /new-services 301
Here an important distiction should be made: A 301 redirect is a permanent forwarding instruction that tells search engines a page has moved for good, and it passes along the “link equity” that page has built up over time. A 302 redirect, on the other hand, is temporary. It’s useful if you’re making short-term changes but don’t want search engines to treat the move as permanent.
In most redesigns, a 301 redirect is the best choice because your new structure is intended to last, and you want Google to fully transfer the authority from the old page to the new one. A 302 is more suitable if you’re only testing a new layout or running a time-limited campaign, but not for permanent redesigns.
Creation of Draft Duplicate Pages
In Squarespace, one of the simplest yet most effective practices is to create duplicate versions of the pages you want to redesign. By working on drafts instead of editing live pages, you protect your current site experience and avoid disrupting your visitors.
It also gives you the space to experiment; to try new layouts, rework your content, and preview how everything flows, without the stress of making permanent changes too early.
Key Elements to Preserve & Pay Attention To
Overall, a redesign is a wonderful opportunity to give your website a fresh look, but certain foundational elements must be carefully preserved. They’re what keep your SEO stable and allow your growth to continue.
Below we list the key elements you’ll want to protect and nurture during the redesign process, so that your site not only looks beautiful but also continues to serve your audience and perform well in search.
URL
Your URLs are like the permanent addresses of your web pages. When they suddenly change without a redirect, search engines and visitors may get lost. Keeping URLs consistent where possible helps preserve rankings and avoids unnecessary SEO disruptions.
Making a list of 301 redirects not only ensures all URLs from your old site have been properly forwarded to their new destinations, but also preserves the trust and link equity those pages have built over time.
SEO Meta Tags
Meta titles and descriptions are the snippets your visitors see in search results, and they tell Google what your page is about. To protect your SEO during a redesign, make sure to:
Carry over all existing meta titles and descriptions into the new design.
Keep them aligned with your primary keywords so they remain relevant.
Write them at the optimal length (50–60 characters for titles, 150–160 characters for descriptions).
Consistency here keeps your hard-earned search presence intact.
H1 & Main Headings
Headings are not only a design element but also a map for search engines. Always keep a clear H1 tag on each page and make sure it contains your primary keyword. Preserving a familiar heading hierarchy (H1, H2, H3) gives both visitors and Google the clarity they need to understand your content.
Content & UX Design
While design itself isn’t a direct ranking factor, your content and user experience deeply influence SEO. A thoughtful redesign should preserve your most valuable content while also making it easier to read, navigate, and engage with. When your visitors stay longer and interact more, Google interprets that as a sign of quality, which can boost your rankings.
Schema Markups
Schema markup is often overlooked, yet it helps search engines better understand the context of your content. Whether it’s marking up reviews, events, or FAQs, these small snippets of code can enhance your visibility with rich results. Preserving them during a redesign ensures Google continues to see and showcase your content in meaningful ways.
With the rise of AI-powered tools, creating and maintaining consistent schema markup across every page has become easier than ever, giving even small businesses the ability to compete for richer search visibility.
To make sure your schema is set up correctly, you can test it with free tools such as:
Google’s Rich Results Test: to see if your pages are eligible for enhanced search display.
Schema Markup Validator: to check whether your schema is properly implemented.
These tools will show you exactly what search engines are reading from your site, giving you peace of mind that nothing was lost during the redesign.
Image Optimisation
Images bring warmth and personality to your site, but oversized or unoptimized ones can slow it down. Aim to keep images in the 250KB–500KB range, use descriptive file names, and add alt text so search engines know what the image represents. Free tools like TinyPNG or ImageOptim can help reduce file sizes without losing quality.
Page Speed Check
A slow website can frustrate visitors and hurt rankings. SEMrush notes that site speed is not just a UX concern but also a critical SEO factor (SEMrush, 2023). Tools like Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix can give you a detailed look at what’s slowing things down so you can fix issues before launch.
In GTmetrix, testing your site speed is simple:
Enter your website URL and run a quick test.
Get a detailed report within moments showing how fast your site loads.
Review recommendations such as compressing large images, optimizing scripts, or reducing server delays.
By addressing these issues, you’ll create a smoother experience for visitors and protect your SEO performance.
Mobile Version Check
More than half of web traffic comes from mobile devices, yet mobile optimization is often overlooked. SEMrush highlights that Google prioritizes mobile-first indexing, meaning your mobile design is the primary version search engines consider (SEMrush, 2023).
In Squarespace, keeping your mobile design smooth and welcoming is simple:
Preview your site on different screen sizes directly within Squarespace.
Run it through Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test to ensure it meets Google’s standards.
Catch small but important issues like layout shifts, tiny text, or images that don’t scale properly.
When your mobile experience is well-preserved, Google rewards your site in rankings and your visitors feel cared for, no matter what device they’re using to connect with you.
Internal & External Links
Internal links connect your content and guide visitors deeper into your site, while external links point to trusted resources that reinforce your credibility. SEMrush explains that both signal to Google that your content is relevant, connected, and trustworthy (SEMrush, 2023).
During a redesign, make sure links are preserved, not broken, and still serve the user experience. The simplest way is to crawl your site with a tool like Screaming Frog or use Google Search Console to flag 404 errors, then update or redirect any broken links.
Taking the time to click through key internal links yourself is also worthwhile, as it lets you experience the site as your visitors would and ensures nothing important gets lost in the shuffle.
Backlinks
Backlinks, meaning links from other websites pointing to yours, are one of the strongest signals of authority. If redesign changes cause those links to break, you lose both traffic and trust. This is why redirects matter so much: they keep those valuable endorsements alive and working for you long after your redesign is complete.
When performing a redesign, make sure to review your top-linked pages using a tool like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Google Search Console, and confirm those pages are either preserved or properly redirected.
By safeguarding your backlinks, you protect not only your SEO rankings but also the relationships and credibility your business has built across the web.
Testing & Monitoring Post-Launch
Launching your redesigned site is exciting, but the work doesn’t end there. The first days and weeks after going live are critical: this is when you monitor, fine-tune, and make sure your SEO strength carries forward into your new design. From our experience redesigning the Kids Science Labs website, we collected and share with you some key steps to consider:
Test Your Site for Core Web Vitals
Google uses Core Web Vitals (CWV), metrics like loading speed, interactivity, and visual stability, to measure user experience, and these directly affect rankings. Ahrefs emphasizes testing your staging site for CWV before and after launch to avoid surprises (Ahrefs, 2023).
You can run a free test using Google PageSpeed Insights: simply enter your site’s URL, and the tool will provide detailed results for both desktop and mobile, along with suggestions to fix any issues. These reports may look technical, but they are your guide to ensuring your site feels fast, stable, and welcoming to every visitor.
In fact, when we worked with Kids Science Labs, running CWV checks before and after launch helped us maintain their site’s speed and stability while rolling out a new design.
On-Page SEO Check on Your New Site
Before you go live, it’s important to double-check that all SEO essentials are in place, meaning titles, meta descriptions, headings, alt text, and structured content. Neil Patel highlights how many sites lose rankings during redesigns simply because these basics weren’t carried over (Patel, 2021).
As mentioned above, at Meraki Branding, we use SEOSpace plugin for Squarespace to run an on-page SEO audit of new designs. It quickly shows if anything is missing, duplicated, or misaligned so we can fix it before search engines and visitors notice. Make sure to download the plugin and give it a go!
From our experience with Kids Science Labs website, the SEOSpace audit helped us spot duplicate meta descriptions and missing alt text that could have impacted their rankings. By addressing these issues before launch, we ensured their SEO foundation stayed strong while the new design went live.
This proactive use of the tool gave them a smooth transition, keeping their search visibility intact and their site polished for visitors from day one.
Update Your Sitemap & Index New Pages
Once your new site is live, you’ll want to guide Google to it as quickly as possible. Start by generating or updating your sitemap in Squarespace (under Settings → SEO), then submit it to Google Search Console. If you’ve hidden draft pages with “no index” tags, remember to remove them so they can be discovered. These small but essential steps ensure your fresh content gets indexed quickly, while outdated URLs are retired gracefully.
Following this process is especially important for websites, like Kids Science Labs, as it allowed us to:
Ensure their newly created program pages were quickly indexed and started ranking in search results.
Prevent older, outdated pages from continuing to appear in Google, which could have confused visitors.
Verify that no draft or hidden pages accidentally remained invisible to search engines after launch.
Give Google a clear and updated map of the site, which helped stabilize their traffic faster post-redesign.
Keyword Monitoring
The first few weeks after a redesign are when you’ll see how your rankings respond. In Google Search Console’s “Performance” tab, you can:
Monitor which keywords are gaining or slipping.
Note any changes, how much traffic they represent, and whether the affected pages are important to your business.
Review pages with consistent drops for missing SEO elements or redirect issues, and update content to better match search intent.
Compare this data with your pre-redesign benchmarks to clearly see what’s working well and where gentle adjustments are needed.
Speaking first-hand, keyword monitoring in GSC was invaluable for our redesign project. It allowed us to quickly identify which of their program pages were temporarily dipping and take action before rankings were lost. Thanks to this close tracking, their SEO performance stabilized quickly and began to grow stronger with the new design.
Flagging of Any Issues & Troubleshooting
Even with the best planning, issues may arise; maybe a redirect didn’t work, or a mobile layout breaks on certain devices. The key is to have a troubleshooting plan.
First, flag the issue clearly (for example: “Broken internal links on Services page”), then identify the possible cause (redirect missing, link typo, caching issue).
Next, test potential fixes one at a time, checking results in Google Search Console or by re-crawling your site.
By approaching troubleshooting step by step, you resolve issues calmly and thoroughly, without creating new problems in the process.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Even with the best intentions, it’s easy to overlook certain details during a redesign that can harm your SEO. Here are four of the most common mistakes we’ve seen, and how you can avoid them with a little care and planning.
Not Setting redirects properly
One common mistake is forgetting to set up 301 redirects when URLs change. Without them, both visitors and search engines encounter broken pages, which can quickly drain your hard-earned trust and rankings.
removing or rewriting high-performing content
This is very common and easily overlooked. Removing or rewriting high-performing content without tracking which pages bring in the most traffic. Experts like Ahrefs show how deleting even a small portion of organic pages can cause a dramatic drop in visibility (Ahrefs, 2024).
ignoring mobile optimization
As mentioned above, moblie optimization is super important in a redesign, as all websites nowadays have a mobile version. A site that doesn’t work smoothly on a phone can frustrate your visitors and send negative signals to Google about user experience.
By making sure buttons are easy to tap, text is comfortable to read, and images resize gracefully, you create a welcoming space that feels natural and trustworthy on any device
launching your staging site without “noindexing” it first
Finally, a subtle but damaging mistake is launching your staging site without “noindexing” it first. As Neil Patel warns, if search engines index your test site, it can create duplicate content issues and confuse Google about which version of your site to trust.
By steering clear of these pitfalls, you’ll give your redesign the best chance to succeed, protecting your SEO while elevating your brand.
How long does it take for SEO to recover after a redesign?
There isn’t a universal timeline for SEO recovery after a redesign, because every site, industry, and redesign process is different.
Some websites may regain their previous rankings in just a few weeks, while others can take several months to stabilize. What matters most is not the exact speed of recovery, but whether the proper steps, such as redirects, audits, mobile optimization, and careful monitoring, have been followed.
If those foundations are in place, recovery is usually smoother and often leads to stronger long-term performance. Rushing or skipping these steps, however, can prolong the recovery period and make it harder to regain lost visibility.
Instead of focusing on the clock, focus on consistency: track your results, fix issues mindfully, and give search engines the signals they need to trust your redesigned site again.
Key Takeaways
Redesigning your website is a beautiful opportunity to refresh your brand, but it also comes with the responsibility of protecting the SEO foundation you’ve built. By preserving key elements like URLs, meta tags, headings, and backlinks, and by carefully planning redirects and monitoring performance post-launch, you can keep your rankings strong while elevating your design.
Small steps, from mobile optimization to schema markup, make a big difference in how search engines and visitors experience your new site. And most importantly, approaching the process with care, patience, and strategy ensures your redesign becomes not just a visual upgrade, but a true step forward for your business growth.
If you wish a professional to guide you through a seamless Squarespace redesign, one that blends thoughtful design with strong SEO practices, our team at Meraki Branding would love to support you every step of the way.
References
Foulkes, R. (2015). How to Avoid an SEO Disaster When Changing Your Website. Moz. Retrieved from https://moz.com/blog/how-to-avoid-an-seo-disaster-when-changing-your-website
Patel, N. (2021). Guide to SEO-Proofing Your Website Redesign. Neil Patel. Retrieved from https://neilpatel.com/blog/safely-redesign-your-website/
Makosiewicz, M. (2023). How to Avoid Ruining SEO During a Website Redesign. Ahrefs Blog. Retrieved from https://ahrefs.com/blog/website-redesign-seo/
SEMrush. (2023). SEO & Web Design: How to Build a Website That Ranks. SEMrush Blog. Retrieved from https://www.semrush.com/blog/seo-web-design/
FAQs on
How to Redesign a Website Without Losing SEO Ranking
-
A site migration usually involves big technical changes, like moving your site to a new domain, hosting provider, or CMS platform. A site redesign, on the other hand, focuses more on visual updates, content refreshes, and improved user experience while keeping the same domain. Both can affect SEO if not handled carefully, but migrations typically carry higher risks.
-
The most important factor is preservation; making sure your existing SEO value (URLs, content, backlinks, and rankings) is carried over into the new design. If you keep what’s working while thoughtfully improving user experience, your SEO will remain strong.
-
Yes, a redesign can affect SEO, but it doesn’t have to be negative. Changes in URLs, structure, or content can cause temporary dips in rankings if not managed well. With careful planning, redirects, and post-launch monitoring, a redesign can actually boost your SEO over time.
-
Start with a full SEO audit of your current site, make a redirect plan for any changed URLs, and ensure that key SEO elements (titles, headings, meta tags, schema, internal links) are preserved. Test your new site thoroughly before launch and monitor results closely after going live.
-
If you’re migrating to a new platform or domain, the key is mapping out every URL and setting up proper 301 redirects. Back up your old site, test everything in a staging environment, and submit an updated sitemap to Google Search Console once you launch. Monitoring traffic and rankings afterward will help you quickly spot and fix any issues.
-
There’s no exact timeline, since recovery depends on the scope of changes and how well they were executed. Some sites bounce back in a few weeks, while others may take several months. Focus on following best practices consistently, and your rankings will stabilize and grow again.
-
Rebranding itself doesn’t hurt SEO, but the changes that come with it, like new content, altered page names, or shifts in site structure, can. If redirects are mapped carefully and your strongest SEO elements are preserved, rebranding can refresh your online presence without sacrificing visibility.
We’d love to hear from you
Contact us and let’s discuss how we can make your project shine.
dimitris
This article was written by Dimitris, the Head of SEO at Meraki Branding.